The Magellan Songbag

I've already blogged some thoughts on why Dirty Projectors' new record Swing Lo Magellan is a masterpiece on the order of Sgt. Pepper or Blood on the Tracks; roughly a week and several listens later, I remain as obsessed with it as I've ever been by any work by anyone. And it strikes me that a huge part of why it's worth it for me to keep plumbing the record for its intricacies of design, arrangement, and production is that it's simply a great bunch of tunes; I'm a song man above most everything else. I respond to groove and timber and instrumentation, but if a songwriter can't also shape an interesting, surprising melody and harmony, I don't much care about the rest.

And with Magellan, lead Projector Dave Longstreth has simply created a trove of amazingly distinctive tunes; he reportedly secluded himself in a cabin to concentrate specifically on songcraft, which is a trick that also led to Bruce Springsteen's best album. All due respect to the Boss, though, as peerless as that bunch of songs is, they don't hold a candle to Longstreth's output here. The range and fecundity of his melodic/harmonic gift is simply astounding.

Indeed, there's only one song out of the record's dozen that I would count as melodically average, though it has other compensatory virtues. And really, the only way I can dig into the joys of SLM's melodies is to sample them all for you. Here goes...

1. Offspring Are Blank. First, I should revise something I said in my earlier Magellan post: Longstreth in fact has begun to write real choruses for many of his songs. The opener is a fine example. First comes the verse melody, which snakes up and down over some prickly minor-modal intervals:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)
  That gets another iteration, then there's an ascending pre-chorus...into a head-banging major-key chorus, in a time signature I can't quite parse:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

An arresting opener, to say the least, though not quite characteristic of the record to come.

2. About To Die. Much more than the opener, this is a handy summation of the Magellan sound, which might be called major-key sunshine with scattered showers and hovering clouds. This one is mostly major all the way, starting with its weird, beguiling verse, which has three measures or 3/4, a single of 2/4, then six of 4/4:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

The joyous chorus alternates consecutive-note runs and chordal leaps, climaxing with the ecstatic title line:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

There's even a delightful bridge with an unmistakable Songs in the Key of Life flavor (the low unison strings as well as the vocal melisma):

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

3. Gun Has No Trigger. I spent some time on this in my previous post. I don't have much to add except to say that this is a remarkable example of a long-line composition; there is no verse or chorus here, just one long 25-bar melody of soaring, minor-to-major majesty. It's the album's greatest piece of songcraft, and it can only be reproduced in full.

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

(By the bye, those last two bars of major-key choralizing over a throbbing bass suggests, to these ears at least, "Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds.")

4. Swing Lo Magellan. Again, a highlight I covered in my last post, with a special emphasis on its unmistakable early-mid-period Dylan influences. Like "Gun" (and like a fair number of Dylan tunes, actually), it's not a verse/chorus structure but one long shape; amid the pointed simplicity of the arrangements and the guitar-based harmonies, I would only point out the odd spaces in the melody (a recurring habit on this record), and note that at bars 10 and 11 (on the words "against the sky" and "a point of light"), and then in the last three bars (14, 15, and 16, on the words "invisible," "give itself," and "naked eye"), the chords change on the second rather than the first beat of the measure, for a gently jolting effect:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

5. Just From Chevron. An epic more on the order of some of the sprawling, complicated tunes of Bitte Orca, but with the higher tunefulness quotient that distinguishes Magellan. We start with a verse melody of folk-like simplicity, and also authentically folk-like oddness; a strange but entirely convincing pause in measure 7 makes this a 9-bar form (or 10-bar, if you count an extra "breather" measure at the end), rather than a standard 8-bar form:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

Dave Longstreth's take on the same verse melody:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

Here's his anguished chorus, distinctive not just for its flailing-in-circles melody but the extraordinary fractal-spray guitar part it's whorling in counterpoint with:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

6. Dance for You. Another resolutely major-key song. I actually prefer this jaunty, confident verse, over a guitar part that reminds me of vintage Liz Phair...

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

(subtly reharmonized on its second iteration, by the way)

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

...to the equivocal chorus, whose final cadence (the title line) is the album's only flirtation with saccharine rather than genuine sweetness, to my ears:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

As some kind of compensation, though, there is this brief orchestral flight, followed by a Fripp-esque two-track guitar solo, one of only a few such on the album.

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

7. Maybe That Was It. The album's only really abstrusely arty song is another long-line composition that's hard to take apart into component parts. It's also such a difficult song, time-signature-wise, that it initially reminded me of Radiohead's seemingly free-time "Pyramid Song" (which apparently someone has figured out). I caught myself humming the whole meandering, eccentric, yearning melody the other day, so I knew it was parse-able; and this morning on the train I think I finally cracked it. I hear the form as 3/4, 5/4, 3/4; then an instrumental fill of 4/4, 4/4, 5/4; repeat all; then there's a 4/4 measure for the title line, followed by four measures of 4/4. The eventual arrival at that even meter, I think, accounts for the relieving sense of a journey completed:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

8. Impregnable Question. Like the album's title tune, a really naked, unadorned piece, and even moreso in its straightforward lyrics. I'm struck here, again, by the curiously unfilled pauses in the melody, which manage to convey a confident lack of hurry and open-hearted comfort (listen after "It would help to seek..." and "comfort in destiny..."):

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

9. See What She Seeing. Like "About to Die," another forward-leaping major-key joy, though with a sunnier, more straightforward lyrical theme. The verse melody, which I read one critic compare to McCartney, at first reminded me a little of Kid A, but that's probably just the frowsy synth accompaniment. I'd agree that this is worthy of Sir Paul at his best:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

The next bit, though technically a chorus, blooms from what came before so naturally that the whole thing feels like one long-line composition:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

10. The Socialites. There's been a fair amount written about the Projectors' homages to R&B (and the props coming right back), but apart from the last album's "Stillness Is the Move" and the stray bit of melisma (like "About To Die's" Stevie Wonder moment above), I don't hear it very strongly. This lovely solo by Amber Coffman is obviously an exception. What makes it work for me is the underselling, not only by Coffman vocally but in the tinkling, harplike thumb-piano arrangement. This doesn't sound like white hipsters trying to throw their weight around in a traditionally black form; instead, it's almost self-consciously delicate, twee, baroque. The verse consists of just this melody four times:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

And then this oddly downcast chorus, which befits the reluctant schadenfreude of the lyric:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

As I noted above, there are more proper choruses on this album than I'd initially thought, but one thing there aren't very many of are bridges. Here's one:


(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

11. Unto Caesar. This harks back more to Dirty Projectors songs of old, where the emphasis has been on cultivating furrows of accompanimental complexity more than on seeding singable tunes per se. Our first cue is this sprightly, offhandedly complicated opening:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

And though this is a thoroughly adequate and likeable verse, it's simply not as inspired as the others on the record:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

An altered second verse then leads directly into a slam-dunk chorus in which the descending sax hook manages to be catchier than the vocal line:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

But in lieu of great melodies, "Unto Caesar" brings a loose party vibe that's almost entirely new for the Projectors (at least on record—I've never had the pleasure of seeing them live), and this soon gives the song over to a series of a calls-and-responses, whoops and hollers. It's utterly disarming, an unexpected romp, and a high-profile melody might just get in the way:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

12. Irresponsible Tune. I haven't talked much about Longstreth's lyrics, which on this record have ranged from opaque to playful to almost embarrassingly straightforward (I'd put a big stress on the almost, which makes all the difference); they are probably worth their own post, but I'll just note here this song is not only a perfect piece of tremulous rockabilly loveliness, it's also a perfect lyric on the theme of art's fundamentally intertwined irresponsibility and necessity. The tune itself might have been written by Felice and Boudleaux Bryant but for the weird short-circuiting that happens in bar 10, when the tune's forward lilt seems to snag on the high note of "lost," where it sits for nearly 8 beats, while the guitar chords tiptoe forward to catch the melody's fall into the final cadence. The result is a distinctly odd but no less gorgeous 14-bar form:

(If player doesn't work, go here to hear the clip.)

As with all the songs on the record, "Irresponsible Tune" comes to an orderly and satisfying close; indeed, there's not a single fade-out on Swing Lo Magellan, another sign, to me at least, that this is a trove of songs as artfully mapped out and composed as any string quartet.

Now, there may be more to a great record than a collection of good tunes. But when this many songs in one collection are this good, I can't help but start thinking of Rubber Soul and Achtung Baby and Up on the Sun, OK Computer and Rhythm of the Saints, Rufus Wainwright and It Takes a Nation of Millions. I'm not sure what the words "genius" and "masterpiece" are for if not for this kind of instantly apprehensible but deeply designed beauty.